# Claw Back SAIL DAO Funding

**URL:** https://forum.osmosis.zone/t/claw-back-sail-dao-funding/2938
**Category:** SAIL
**Tags:** passed
**Created:** [July 14, 2024, 10:13pm UTC](https://forum.osmosis.zone/t/claw-back-sail-dao-funding/2938 "2024-07-14T22:13:25Z")
**Posts on this page:** 1
**Showing post:** 46

<div class="post-metadata">

### Author: ![0xPhilipp](https://sea2.discourse-cdn.com/flex020/user_avatar/forum.osmosis.zone/0xphilipp/32/297_2.png) [@0xPhilipp](https://forum.osmosis.zone/u/0xPhilipp)
#### Post date: [July 17, 2024, 9:15am UTC](https://forum.osmosis.zone/t/claw-back-sail-dao-funding/2938/46 "2024-07-17T09:15:26Z")

</div>

This proposal is just peak corruption.

@RoboMcGobo stop spreading lies. It is not the Osmosis community speaking through you, it is your own opinion with slanderous lies, to get your own agenda through.

Let’s start with reviewing SAIl DAO creation proposal:

> [@Sail With the Whale V2: SAIL DAO (Updated)](https://forum.osmosis.zone/t/sail-with-the-whale-v2-sail-dao-updated/1041):
>
> The Previous proposal #694 “Sail With the Whale” requested deployment of 5 mil OSMO to seed 2 LST pools on White Whale DEX deployed on Osmosis chain. On top of the deployment of WW DEX onto Osmosis, other obligations from the Whale side included integration of OSMO LST’s into Migaloo ecosystem projects as well as further SC deployments and liquidity pools on Osmosis, as is consistent with the “Sail With The Whale” program. Based on community feedback, we have given the first edition of the prop…

1. Fulfilled
2. Fulfilled
3. Fulfilled
4. Fulfilled
5. Fullfilled

Benefits

1. Fulfilled
2. Fulfilled
3. Fulfilled
4. In progress
5. Partially Fulfilled

@RoboMcGobo is questioning a loss of around 77k OSMO ($ 45k).  
But the numbers are a lie and here is why:

Total worth of the provided 3.5 M OSMO today: $ 1.9 M  
Total worth of the LPs @RoboMcGobo wants to clawback: $1,992,053

> [@RoboMcGobo](#):
>
> - 818,567 OSMO [worth appx. $449,207]
> - WHALE / OSMO LP Shares worth appx. $96,000
> - ampOSMO / OSMO LP Shares worth appx. ~~$612,000~~ → $696,974
> - bOSMO / OSMO LP Shares worth appx. ~~$607,000~~ → $691,872
> - Lab / OSMO LP Shares worth appx. $28,000
> - ROAR / OSMO LP Shares worth appx. $30,000

Total worth still in SAIL DAO: $ 339,891

- 642,776,560 SAIL worth appx. $169,493 [excluded]
- 3,601,755 WHALE worth appx. $26,398
- SAIL / WHALE LP Shares worth appx. $130,000
- WHALE / RSTK LP Shares worth appx. $14,000

This comes to a total treasury value of SAIL DAO of $2,331,944

**Comparing this to the “do nothing” case, since the inception of SAIL DAO on 10th January, it created an RoI (Return on Investment) of $431,944. Leading to a yearly APR of 45 % as of today!**

[not counting Apps, Dev Work, Utility, Trading Activity, Arb Vaults, Mad Scientists, Mad Lab, Airdrops for SAIL holders, circulating SAIL, treasury SAIL, future airdrops for Osmosis, bad token price action]

Numbers don’t lie. @RoboMcGobo does.

---

_[View the full topic](https://forum.osmosis.zone/t/claw-back-sail-dao-funding/2938)._